There is a coffee shop near my office that makes a toffee latte that I used to order three times a week. It cost $7 and had approximately 400 calories and I loved every single one of them. Then I found Stevia Select English Toffee Liquid Stevia and made my own at home. My homemade toffee latte now costs about 40 cents and has zero sugar calories. My wallet and my waistline are both very happy with this development.
First Impressions
The 2oz 2-pack arrives cleanly. Ingredients: stevia leaf extract, water, natural English toffee flavoring. No erythritol, no alcohol, no artificial sweeteners. The toffee aroma is warm and genuine — buttery with that distinctive caramel-toffee character. Stevia Select is a small American brand committed to clean flavored stevia drops and this flavor is one of their standouts.
What Makes It Different
Stevia Select’s English Toffee uses natural toffee flavoring blended with pure stevia extract — no erythritol, no artificial ingredients. The toffee note is warm, caramel-adjacent, and slightly buttery. It’s different from their Caramel or Butterscotch varieties — English Toffee has a slightly more complex, deeper sweetness that pairs especially well with coffee and dark tea. BSR around 5,525 with 4.1 stars and consistent reviews shows it has a dedicated following.
Real-World Performance
My go-to is 3 drops in my morning latte — it tastes like a proper toffee latte from a café, without the guilt or the price tag. My husband has declared it his second favorite stevia flavor after Enzo’s Toffee Caramel. In hot chocolate it’s extraordinary — adds a toffee layer that makes sugar-free cocoa feel genuinely indulgent. Also works beautifully in overnight oats and plain yogurt. NOT for baking — Enzo EasyUse Powder handles that.
Long-Term Value
Two bottles at $25.50 is fair for natural toffee flavoring. At approximately 100 servings per bottle, the 2-pack gives 200 total servings. Stevia Select’s English Toffee consistently ranks among their top sellers for good reason — the flavor is genuinely excellent and stands up to repeated daily use without becoming tiresome.
Final Verdict: 8.9/10
- Natural English Toffee flavor — warm, buttery, caramel-complex
- ~200 total servings across both bottles
- No erythritol, no alcohol, no artificial ingredients
- Non-GMO, keto, vegan and diabetic friendly
- NOT for baking — use powder instead
- 2oz size needs more frequent repurchasing
Tips for Success
- Start with 2–3 drops per cup and adjust to taste
- Best in coffee, hot cocoa, oatmeal, milk-based drinks
- Refrigerate after opening for best freshness
- For baking, use Enzo EasyUse Powder instead
Until next time, keep it sweet and toffee! 🍬 #SteviaSelect #EnglishToffeeStevia #LiquidStevia #ZeroCalorie #BestSteviaSweetener
Check some total thoughts
Pros and Cons Values
Product specification
Specification for product
| SPEC | |
|---|---|
| Size | 2 fl oz (Pack of 2) |
| Servings | ~200 total |
| Flavor | English Toffee |
| Calories | 0 |
| Erythritol-Free | Yes |
| Non-GMO | Yes |
| Alcohol-Free | Yes |
| ASIN | B0BQ21HHGW |
Security testing
What about security?
Stevia may cause allergic reactions in people with allergies to chrysanthemums, marigolds, ragweed, or daisies. Not recommended for pregnant or lactating women or children without consulting a healthcare provider. These statements have not been evaluated by the FDA and are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease. For returns, contact Stevia Select directly.
Compare with Other
How it’s good with competitors
Stevia Select English Toffee vs other toffee-flavored liquid stevias:
Price list of packages?
Where to Buy and price list
- Refunds handled directly by Stevia Select — not through Amazon
- Ships via Amazon FBA with Prime delivery
- 2-pack format covers home and travel
People Also Ask
How do I make a toffee latte at home with stevia?
Brew your espresso or strong coffee. Add 3–4 drops of English Toffee stevia drops directly to the cup before adding milk. Steam or froth your milk of choice (dairy, oat, or almond all work well). Pour the milk over the sweetened espresso and stir once. The result is a toffee latte that tastes genuinely coffeehouse-quality — at home, for under 50 cents, with zero added sugar.
What is the difference between Stevia Select toffee and SweetLeaf toffee?
Both use natural English toffee flavoring with pure stevia extract and no erythritol. The main difference is brand heritage — SweetLeaf has 40+ years in the stevia market with organic certification, while Stevia Select is a newer small-batch American brand. In blind taste tests our team finds them very comparable; SweetLeaf edges ahead slightly on consistency while Stevia Select occasionally delivers a slightly deeper butterscotch note that some users prefer.
Is toffee stevia keto-friendly?
English toffee stevia drops are fully keto-compatible. With zero calories, zero carbohydrates, and a glycemic index of zero, they have no impact on blood sugar or insulin. The natural toffee flavoring used contains no sugars or carbohydrates. Toffee stevia is one of the most popular flavors in the keto community specifically because it creates a coffeehouse-quality flavored coffee without any carbs.
Can toffee stevia drops be used in hot chocolate?
Toffee stevia drops are outstanding in hot chocolate. Add 3–4 drops to your sugar-free cocoa mix before adding the liquid for best flavor integration. The combination of dark chocolate and English toffee creates a mocha-toffee layered flavor that makes sugar-free hot cocoa taste genuinely indulgent. It’s one of the most recommended flavor pairings in the sugar-free beverage community.
Pages that search results are linking to (excluding internal links):
SERP
SteviaSelect.com — English Toffee Drops — Brand page covering ingredient sourcing, flavor profile description, and recommended usage for the full Stevia Select flavor lineup including English Toffee. (steviaselect.com)
Amazon — Stevia Select English Toffee (B0BQ21HHGW) — Buyer reviews comparing flavor accuracy to coffeehouse toffee syrups, daily coffee use feedback, and repeat purchase patterns. (amazon.com)
Bulletproof Blog: Best Flavors for Keto Coffee — Coverage of flavored stevia drops for bulletproof and keto coffee, including toffee varieties for daily mocha and latte alternatives. (bulletproof.com)
Reddit r/keto: Toffee Stevia Latte Recipe Thread — Community discussion on recreating coffeehouse toffee lattes at home using stevia drops, comparing Stevia Select, SweetLeaf, and Enzo toffee caramel varieties. (reddit.com)
Keto Connect: Best Flavored Stevia for Coffee Shop Dupes — Ranked guide to using flavored stevia drops to recreate popular coffeehouse drinks at home for a fraction of the cost and calories. (ketoconnect.net)
Top 20 Topics
Topics sorted by frequency across top search results:
Stevia Select toffee · English toffee stevia · toffee latte · keto toffee latte · coffee shop dupe · natural toffee flavor · buttery sweetness · zero calorie toffee · no erythritol · no alcohol · keto coffee · hot cocoa · butterscotch notes · small-batch brand · 200 servings · 2-pack · non-GMO · oatmeal sweetener · plant-based · diabetic toffee
Topic Clusters:
Toffee Flavor Profile — English toffee · buttery character · butterscotch depth · caramel-adjacent · warm richness · not synthetic
Coffee Shop Dupe — toffee latte · home barista · 40-cent latte · keto coffee shop · save money · zero sugar
Brand & Formula — Stevia Select brand · clean ingredients · no erythritol · no alcohol · natural flavoring · small-batch
Diet & Health — keto · diabetic friendly · zero calorie · zero carb · non-GMO · sugar-free