Stevia Select Vanilla Liquid Stevia 2oz 2-Pack Review

My grandmother made the best vanilla pudding in the world. She used real vanilla beans and whole milk and I can still smell it when I close my eyes. I can’t recreate that pudding — but I can put Stevia Select Vanilla in my coffee every morning and feel a little bit of that warmth. My daughter thinks this is sentimental nonsense. She also asked me to put it in her morning yogurt, so who’s the winner here.

First Impressions

Two 2oz dropper bottles, cleanly packaged. Ingredients: stevia leaf extract, water, natural vanilla flavoring. No erythritol, no alcohol, no artificial sweeteners. The vanilla aroma is clean and genuine — not the synthetic vanilla-adjacent smell of cheaper products. Stevia Select uses natural vanilla flavoring that delivers a light, fresh vanilla note rather than a heavy cream flavor.

What Makes It Different

Stevia Select’s Vanilla is lighter and fresher than SweetLeaf’s Vanilla Crème — less dessert-like, more like a fresh vanilla bean note. No erythritol, no artificial ingredients. The 2oz 2-pack is practical for daily use. BSR around 6,085 with 4.1 stars shows consistent strong sales across the entire Stevia Select flavor line.

Real-World Performance

In coffee it’s wonderful — 3 drops creates a gentle vanilla latte effect without any coffee shop required. The vanilla note is clean and genuine, not synthetic. In yogurt, smoothies, and protein shakes the vanilla note adds a pleasant background sweetness. My daughter uses it in her banana smoothies and says it makes them taste “more dessert-y.” In sparkling water with a tiny splash of cream it’s genuinely refreshing. NOT for baking. Use Enzo EasyUse Powder for baking.

Long-Term Value

Two bottles at $25.50 for natural vanilla flavoring is fair. At approximately 100 servings per bottle, the 2-pack gives 200 total servings. Vanilla is one of the most versatile stevia flavors — it works across coffee, tea, yogurt, smoothies, and sparkling water, making every serving count.

Final Verdict: 8.9/10

• Clean, genuine vanilla flavor — fresh and natural tasting
• ~200 total servings across both bottles
• No erythritol, no alcohol, no artificial ingredients
• Non-GMO, keto, vegan and diabetic friendly
• NOT for baking — use powder instead
• 2oz size needs more frequent repurchasing

Tips for Success

• Start with 2–3 drops per cup and adjust to taste
• Best in coffee, tea, yogurt, smoothies, sparkling water with cream
• Refrigerate after opening for best freshness
• For baking, use Enzo EasyUse Powder instead

Until next time, keep it sweet and vanilla! 🌿 #SteviaSelect #VanillaStevia #LiquidStevia #ZeroCalorie #BestSteviaSweetener

Stevia may cause allergic reactions in people with allergies to chrysanthemums, marigolds, ragweed, or daisies. Not recommended for pregnant or lactating women or children without consulting a healthcare provider. These statements have not been evaluated by the FDA and are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease. For returns, contact Stevia Select directly.

Stevia Select Vanilla vs other vanilla-flavored liquid stevias:

Stevia Select Vanilla vs NuNaturals Vanilla vs SweetLeaf Vanilla CrèmeVersus subline

VS

VS

EnzoStevia.com Best Values

Our top-rated stevia brand

$16.99$20 buy direct

Use coupon AWESOME for 3% discount

Amazon Best Price

Stevia Select Vanilla 2oz 2-Pack on Amazon

$25.50$30.00 Amazon

What is the best vanilla stevia for coffee?

The best vanilla stevia for coffee depends on the flavor intensity you prefer. For a light, fresh vanilla bean note, Stevia Select Vanilla is excellent — subtle enough not to overpower the coffee. For a richer, creamier vanilla dessert profile, SweetLeaf Vanilla Crème delivers more intensity. For daily use where you want just a hint of vanilla in every cup, Stevia Select’s lighter formula is the better fit.

Is vanilla stevia the same as vanilla extract?

Vanilla stevia drops and vanilla extract are different products. Vanilla extract provides vanilla flavor but contains alcohol (35%+ in standard extract) and is used primarily in baking. Vanilla stevia drops combine stevia sweetness with natural vanilla flavoring and are designed for beverages. Vanilla stevia is zero calorie with no alcohol; vanilla extract adds flavor but negligible sweetness. They’re not interchangeable — vanilla stevia is for sweetening and flavoring drinks, not baking.

Can I use vanilla stevia in yogurt?

Vanilla stevia drops work beautifully in plain or Greek yogurt. Add 2–3 drops to a serving of plain yogurt and stir well — the result is a lightly sweetened vanilla yogurt without any added sugar. Pair with fresh berries or granola for a genuinely satisfying sugar-free breakfast or snack. The vanilla note is light enough to complement the yogurt’s natural tang rather than overpowering it.

How does Stevia Select vanilla compare to NuNaturals vanilla?

Stevia Select Vanilla uses a lighter, fresher natural vanilla flavoring with a clean stevia extract and water base — no erythritol, no alcohol. NuNaturals Vanilla also uses natural vanilla flavoring with their pure stevia extract but typically delivers a slightly more robust vanilla character. Both are clean, erythritol-free formulas; the choice comes down to whether you prefer lighter (Stevia Select) or deeper (NuNaturals) vanilla intensity in your daily beverages.

SteviaSelect.com — Vanilla Drops — Brand page with natural vanilla sourcing information, usage recommendations across beverages, and comparison to the Stevia Select flavor lineup. (steviaselect.com)

Amazon — Stevia Select Vanilla (B0BP5FPNW4) — Verified buyer reviews covering vanilla intensity in coffee, yogurt, and smoothie applications with direct comparisons to SweetLeaf and NuNaturals vanilla options. (amazon.com)

Skinnytaste: Sugar-Free Vanilla Coffee Recipes — Popular healthy recipe blog featuring vanilla stevia drops in sugar-free vanilla lattes, iced coffee, and vanilla yogurt parfait recipes. (skinnytaste.com)

Healthful Pursuit: Vanilla Keto Coffee Guide — Keto nutrition guide covering the best vanilla sweeteners for fat-adapted coffee drinkers, including liquid stevia drop recommendations and dosing tips. (healthfulpursuit.com)

Reddit r/xxketo: Best Vanilla Stevia for Coffee Thread — Female keto community discussion comparing vanilla stevia options for daily coffee use, with Stevia Select and SweetLeaf both featured with user taste notes. (reddit.com)

Topics sorted by frequency across top search results:

vanilla stevia · Stevia Select vanilla · vanilla latte · vanilla coffee drops · natural vanilla flavor · fresh vanilla bean · zero calorie vanilla · no erythritol · no alcohol · keto vanilla · yogurt sweetener · smoothie vanilla · versatile flavor · small-batch brand · 200 servings · 2-pack · non-GMO · banana smoothie · plant-based · diabetic vanilla

Topic Clusters:

Vanilla Flavor Profile — fresh vanilla bean · light character · not synthetic · clean note · natural flavoring · less dessert-like

Versatile Applications — vanilla latte · yogurt · banana smoothie · protein shake · sparkling water · overnight oats

Brand & Formula — Stevia Select brand · clean ingredients · no erythritol · no alcohol · natural flavoring · small-batch

Diet & Health — keto · diabetic friendly · zero calorie · non-GMO · sugar-free · versatile daily flavor